Story

Salina staff recommends second-lowest bid for $1,018,783 Overlook Estates water line extension

November 19, 2026 Salina311, Salina City Commission, Overlook Estates, water line, Markley Road, Smoky Hill LLC, PSE Contractors, special improvement district, Great Life Golf Course, fire protection, River Run, Salina utilities, Salina
Salina staff recommends second-lowest bid for $1,018,783 Overlook Estates water line extension

City staff is recommending that the Salina City Commission award a water line contract to the second-lowest bidder, saying the low bidder is unlikely to meet the project schedule, according to the commission packet for Monday's meeting.

The commission will consider awarding Project No. 25031, the Overlook Estates Water Line Extension, to Smoky Hill, LLC of Salina for $970,270 with a $48,513 construction contingency, for a total not to exceed $1,018,783. In a related item, it will consider Resolution No. 26-8390, which would create a special improvement district to help pay for the line from Markley Road to the Overlook Estates Addition.

Why the line is needed

The Planning Commission approved the final plat of Overlook Estates on March 21, 2023, on the condition that a second public water line connection to Markley Road be completed and operating before any vertical construction in the subdivision, according to a staff report from Rex Ritter, deputy director of public works.

A staff report from Jeff Shamburg, deputy director of utilities, says the existing water system serving Overlook Estates provides limited fire flow and no redundancy. The new line would add a second source and improve fire protection. The main is also sized for future development between Overlook Estates and Markley Road, extending south to Magnolia Road, according to the report.

An annexation agreement between the city and Vanier Properties obligates the city to design and build the looped connection, according to the staff report. The city says the line has been designed and the easements acquired.

The bids

Six bids were opened Oct. 15, according to the staff report:

  • PSE Contractors, LLC of Wichita, $929,284
  • Smoky Hill, LLC of Salina, $970,270.25
  • Kansas Concrete, LLC of Nickerson, $1,063,378
  • Nowak Construction Co., Inc. of Goddard, $1,135,966
  • T&R Construction of Salina, $1,198,690
  • JC Builders, Inc. of Salina, $1,572,670

The engineer's estimate was $1,189,300.

Staff wrote that the city has not previously worked with PSE. Of nine projects PSE submitted as references, two were comparable in size and type, both for the city of Wichita. One, a $1.2 million water line, finished ahead of schedule, and the other, a $1.8 million water main project, finished more than a month after its contract completion date, according to the report.

Staff also contacted the city of Andover, where PSE has indicated it will not meet a Dec. 3 substantial completion deadline, and other water utilities that "echoed similar concerns" about on-time completion, according to the report.

The Salina project requires a three-week completion period for part of the work to minimize disruption to the Great Life Golf Course and has a final completion date of June 30, 2027. "Given PSE's limited comparable project history and recent schedule performance, staff does not believe PSE can reliably meet the project schedule," the report says.

Staff says Smoky Hill has completed numerous city projects, including water main replacements, that met or exceeded expectations. Its bid is $219,029.75 below the engineer's estimate, and staff believes the $40,986.25 difference from the low bid is justified, according to the report.

Who pays

The estimated total cost of the water line improvements is $1,201,153.65, according to the draft resolution. The improvement district, Lots 1 through 11 of Block 1 in Overlook Estates, would be assessed 9.23% of the cost, and the city at large would pay 90.77%, according to the staff report.

Property owners in the district could pay their share in a lump sum or as a special assessment over 20 years. Property owners in River Run would not be assessed, according to the staff report. The city's share would be funded with bonds supported by the Water/Wastewater Fund.

The petition for the district, Petition 4450, meets the state requirement because it is signed by owners of more than half of the area to be assessed, and the Saline County treasurer reported no delinquent special assessments on the petitioners' property, according to staff. Property outside city limits that would benefit from the line could be charged benefit fees later under state law, with the money used to reimburse the city's share, according to the report.

The commission meets at 4 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23, in Room 107 of the City-County Building, 300 W. Ash St. The meeting is also available on Zoom and on the city's YouTube channel, according to the agenda.

The agenda and supporting documents are posted on the city's meeting portal.

Share this story
Printed for Salina

Get the newspaper or the Monthly Almanac

The newspaper

Weekly print edition

The week in Salina, on paper. Local stories, events, and where your neighbors stand.

Salina311 newspaper
$21.45/mo
Delivered every Sunday · $257.40/yr
Get the newspaper
Not a newspaper

The Monthly Almanac

A 32-page record of last month, the numbers that matter, and the month ahead.

Monthly Almanac
$10.70/mo
Delivered at the beginning of each month · $128.40/yr
Get the Monthly Almanac
Salina311

Sign In